From Accidents to Assets
The value pathways of patents for serendipitous inventions
By Christoph Grimpe, Karin Hoisl, Myriam Mariani & Wolfgang Sofka
November, 2026
From Accidents to Assets
The value pathways of patents for serendipitous inventions
By Christoph Grimpe, Karin Hoisl, Myriam Mariani & Wolfgang Sofka
November, 2026
This post is based on
Grimpe, C., Hoisl, K., Mariani, M., & Sofka, W. (2026). From accidents to assets-The value pathways of patents for serendipitous inventions. Strategic Management Journal, 1–52. https://doi.org/10.1002/smj.70126
We love stories of accidental breakthroughs. Penicillin, Velcro, Post-it Notes, and microwave ovens have become iconic examples of how unexpected inventions can transform industries. These stories have helped fuel the belief that serendipity is one of innovation's most powerful forces (Austin, Devin, & Sullivan, 2011; Busch, 2024).
But an important question remains: What happens to serendipitous inventions after they are made? More specifically, how do firms actually create value from them?
In our recent paper, we examined this question using data from more than 8,500 patented inventions across 23 countries. The findings challenge some common assumptions about serendipity and offer practical lessons for managers seeking to balance planned innovation with unexpected opportunities.
Serendipity is more common than we think
When people think about serendipitous inventions, they often imagine rare strokes of genius or lucky accidents. Yet our data suggest that serendipity is far from unusual. Using a large-scale inventor survey linked to patent data, we found that approximately 43% of patented inventions can be classified as serendipitous, meaning they emerged as unexpected by-products of research & development (R&D) projects or arose outside formal R&D efforts altogether.
These inventions often look different from their planned counterparts. They are more likely to originate from smaller projects, individual efforts, leisure-time experimentation, and work environments that provide inventors with greater autonomy. They are also more likely to emerge when information flows freely across organizational boundaries.
In short, serendipity is not simply luck. It appears to flourish in environments that give people room to explore, connect ideas, and pursue unexpected insights (Busch, 2024; Cockburn, Henderson, & Stern, 2000).
Not every accidental discovery becomes a post-it note
The popular narrative surrounding serendipity is shaped by spectacular success stories. Yet relying solely on famous examples can be misleading. To understand the average value of serendipitous patented inventions, we compared them with inventions that resulted from planned R&D efforts. We focused on four pathways through which patented inventions create value: (1) technological impact, (2) internal commercialization, (3) competitor blocking, and (4) licensing to external organizations.
On average, serendipitous patented inventions receive fewer future patent citations, making them less likely to become influential building blocks for subsequent technological developments. They are also less likely to be incorporated into products and services developed by the originating firm. Finally, they are less likely to be used strategically to block competitors through patent portfolios.
This does not mean that serendipitous inventions lack value. But it suggests that they may follow a different commercialization path.
Why firms struggle to exploit serendipitous inventions
One reason is fit. Planned inventions usually emerge within established R&D programs. Firms have already identified target markets, allocated resources, assembled complementary capabilities, and developed commercialization plans. The invention is designed with a clear purpose in mind (Cooper & Kleinschmidt, 2011; Teece, 1986).
Serendipitous inventions are different. By definition, they arise unexpectedly. As a result, they often are located outside a firm's existing knowledge base, strategic priorities, or product roadmap. Our analysis supports this idea (Cattani, 2005, 2006). We found that serendipitous inventions exhibit lower knowledge fit with the originating organization's existing technological portfolio than planned inventions.
This misalignment creates challenges. Even when an invention has significant potential, the firm may lack the manufacturing capabilities, distribution channels, regulatory expertise, or market access needed to turn it into a successful product. In other cases, managers may simply struggle to see how the invention fits within current strategic priorities.
The unexpected value pathway: licensing
While serendipitous inventions are less likely to generate value through internal commercialization, they are more likely to be licensed to external organizations. This finding suggests that instead of viewing them primarily as future products, firms may benefit from viewing them as option-like assets (Bowman & Hurry, 1993). Even when an invention does not fit the originating firm's strategy, it may fit perfectly with another organization.
Markets for technology provide a mechanism for realizing that value. Through licensing firms can monetize inventions that would otherwise remain underutilized. In this sense, the value of serendipitous inventions may often lie not in what the originating firm does with them, but in what someone else can do with them (Arora, Fosfuri, & Gambardella, 2001; Arora & Gambardella, 2010).
Why this matters
Our findings offer several practical implications. First, managers should recognize that serendipitous inventions are not rare anomalies. They represent a substantial share of innovative activity and deserve systematic attention.
Second, organizations should develop processes for evaluating unexpected inventions separately from their formal innovation pipeline. Applying the same criteria used for planned projects may cause valuable opportunities to be overlooked.
Finally, firms that frequently generate serendipitous inventions may benefit from strengthening their technology licensing and commercialization capabilities. Strong external networks and access to technology markets can help transform unexpected inventions into valuable business assets.
Beyond luck
Serendipity occupies a fascinating space between chance and strategy. Unexpected inventions may arise without planning, but value creation rarely happens by accident. Our research shows that serendipitous inventions often travel different paths than planned innovations. They may fit less well with the organizations that create them, but they can still generate substantial value when transferred to those better positioned to exploit them. The lesson is simple: Firms should not just celebrate accidental inventions. They should build the capabilities needed to turn accidents into assets.
Author bio
Christoph Grimpe is a Professor of Innovation and Entrepreneurship at the Department of Strategy and Innovation at Copenhagen Business School (CBS), DK. He is affiliated with the Leibniz Centre for European Economic Research (ZEW). He serves on the council of the Independent Research Fund Denmark. His primary research areas are innovation strategy and search, intellectual property, technology markets & corporate acquisitions, international business, human capital & innovation, and science, technology & innovation policy.
Karin Hoisl is a Professor of Organization and Innovation at the University of Mannheim, DE. She is also a part-time professor of the Economics and Management of Inventive Processes in the Department of Strategy and Innovation at Copenhagen Business School, and a research affiliate at the Max Planck Institute for Innovation and Competition in Munich. Her primary research areas are gender gaps in STEM, digital transformation & the future of work, and innovation in extreme environments.
Myriam Mariani is a Professor of Applied Economics at the Department of Management and Technology at Bocconi University, Milan, IT. She is affiliated with the Invernizzi Center for research on innovation, organization, strategy and entrepreneurship (ICRIOS). Her primary research areas are inventors’ job motivations and knowledge transmission during the inventive process and women in STEM.
Wolfgang Sofka is a Professor for Strategic and International Management at the Department of Strategy and Innovation at Copenhagen Business School (CBS), DK. He is also a part-time professor for International Business at the University of Liverpool Management School, UK. His primary research areas are strategic human capital, capturing value from innovation, and internationalization.
Further reading on this topic
Arora, A., Fosfuri, A., & Gambardella, A. (2001). Markets for technology and their implications for corporate strategy. Industrial and Corporate Change, 10(2), 419–451.
Arora, A., & Gambardella, A. (2010). Ideas for rent: An overview of markets for technology. Industrial and Corporate Change, 19(3), 775–803.
Austin, R. D., Devin, L., & Sullivan, E. E. (2011). Accidental innovation: Supporting valuable unpredictability in the creative process. Organization Science, 23(5), 1505–1522.
Bowman, E. H., & Hurry, D. (1993). Strategy through the option lens: An integrated view of resource investments and the incremental-choice process. Academy of Management Review, 18(4), 760–782.
Busch, C. (2024). Towards a theory of serendipity: A systematic review and conceptualization. Journal of Management Studies, 61(3), 1110–1151.
Cattani, G. (2005). Preadaptation, firm heterogeneity, and technological performance: A study on the evolution of fiber optics, 1970–1995. Organization Science, 16(6), 563–580.
Cattani, G. (2006). Technological pre-adaptation, speciation, and emergence of new technologies: How corning invented and developed fiber optics. Industrial and Corporate Change, 15(2), 285–318.
Cockburn, I. M., Henderson, R., & Stern, S. (2018). The impact of artificial intelligence on innovation. NBER Working Paper 24449.
Cooper, R. G., & Kleinschmidt, E. J. (2011). New products: The key factors in success. Marketing Classics Press.
Grimpe, C., Hoisl, K., Mariani, M., & Sofka, W. (2026). From accidents to assets—The value pathways of patents for serendipitous inventions. Strategic Management Journal, forthcoming.
Teece, D. J. (1986). Profiting from technological innovation: Implications for integration, collaboration, licensing and public policy. Research Policy, 16, 285–305.